Amazing Grace: How I hate the sound
March 11, 2011
Over the weekend, I was siting next to one of my best friends. We had been having a pretty awesome game of would-you-rather and it was my turn to come up with a situation. While she waited for me, she started humming Amazing Grace. Three bars in, I turned to her, my face dark with hate and whispered as if possessed “I hate that song.” I have always hated that song. It awakens a deep, dark, hatred in me and I don’t know why. However, I think I can pinpoint a few reasons.
First off, I don’t like how it’s used. If something sad happens on TV, this song kicks in. If someone dies and we are supposed to feel sad, this is the soundtrack. How stupid. If something is sad, shouldn’t we feel sad with out some heavy handed symbolic music? In a script, if your sad moment doesn’t make your reader feel sad, you are a bad writer. If you are an actor and you can’t convey sadness in a way that makes your audience emote, you are a bad actor. If you are a director and you can’t orchestrate a sad moment with out Amazing Grace, you are a bad director. Improve your craft. Don’t rely on some bloody song.
Another annoying thing is the history. Not many people know this, but Amazing Grace was written by a reformed slave trader. He was a “wretch” but “was found.” Okay. Listen, I appreciate forgiveness and second chances. It’s a very nice thing, but really? When you think about it, one slave trader selling one person into inescapable bondage has horrible consequences for generations of the slave’s family. So keep that in mind when this is being sung by a gospel choir during a funeral. That’s a really awkward place put a song about being redeemed after a life of human trafficking.
I don’t like the way it is sung, I don’t like the way it is overused and I don’t like to see pictures of sad SPCA animals while this song plays in the background.But worst of all is this:
[Super Sarcastic Mode] My name is embedded in the title! How dare they!! Yes, I am Amazing, but this song is not.[End Super Sarcastic Mode]
I guess we all have our pet peeves, some more idiosyncratic than others. We all have things that bring us comfort, some more cliche and overwrought than others.
All I know is if this is played in my funeral, I will jump out of the coffin and straight up dropkick whoever let this happen.
Miss Ann Thrope • Apr 6, 2021 at 12:32 pm
I did a search for ‘I hate Amazing Grace’ and found this. You’re doing a wonderful service to Amazing Grace haters everywhere. The melody is whiny and simplistic. The forced gratitude is maudlin and childish. And the back story is not only NOT inspiring, it’s disgusting. (Not the anti-slavery that Xtians pretend it is!):
https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/amazing-grace/
Brian • Feb 8, 2021 at 1:47 am
This song is just really lame. Don’t get me wrong, I love a sappy love song like Perfect by Ed Sheeran, but Amazing Grace is just a really lame boring song
Christine Cooney • Jan 21, 2021 at 12:13 am
I also cannot stand this song (agree , bagpipes make it intolerable). I don’t like the generalized expression of ‘wretchedness” . Such expressions should be directed to the person or persons you have harmed. or privately, in prayer, if you are a believer. But most of all, the “melody” is so boring and sing-song.. Maybe Bruce Springsteen could pull it off, as he does in “Born in the USA”, a tune of 3 notes.
Karl Baxter • Jan 20, 2021 at 8:16 am
I find a “normal” rendition of AG just about tolerable but when it gets stretched out to interminable lengths with all manner of vocal gymnastics and histrionics I reach for the off button. Is there a secret competition among solo singers to mangle it for as long as possible until it resembles a sick animal that longs for sweet euthanasia? It doesn’t make me feel emotional or tearful – just makes me think “Please make it stop!”.
Frank • Dec 30, 2020 at 1:52 pm
I couldn’t agree more. I despise this song and whenever I hear it I cringe! I though I was the only one. Thanks.
Roger • Jul 26, 2020 at 9:49 pm
That ” wretch” of a song should only be sung in the third person; i.e., he was once lost, etc. Don’t call others a ” wretch” A former slave trader was anded never will be in a position to so so. I have wonder about the authenticity of his salvation. I think he was always demon possessed . For that reason, he called others wretch, in an accusatory manner, unlike the Christian he falsely attempted to so portray himself.
Mark • Nov 19, 2017 at 1:36 pm
I totally agree. I never understood why it was so popular and beloved and for some reason, funeral friendly.
Gary • Mar 13, 2014 at 1:00 am
The only thing worse than “Amazing Grace” is “Amazing Grace” played on bagpipes. Hey, just a minute… Amazing Grace? I think I used to date her…
John • Apr 5, 2011 at 2:09 pm
some american you are. rethink what you are saying
John • Apr 5, 2011 at 2:09 pm
some american you are. rethink what you are saying
Ama • Mar 17, 2011 at 9:25 pm
Heh. This is obviously a song about us, Grace.
Ama • Mar 17, 2011 at 9:25 pm
Heh. This is obviously a song about us, Grace.
Grace • Mar 17, 2011 at 12:38 pm
my name is embedded in the title…huh…
Grace • Mar 17, 2011 at 12:38 pm
my name is embedded in the title…huh…